What Would You Do With Superpowers? (Honestly? Something Petty First)

Ask anyone what they would do with superpowers and you get the brochure answer. Fly. Save people from burning buildings. Stop wars, possibly before lunch. It's a lovely answer, and I don't believe a word of it - including when I give it myself. Because the honest answer to "what would you do with superpowers" isn't a mission statement. It's a list. And the top of the list is almost always something small, specific and slightly embarrassing.

Think about the first forty-eight hours. Not the first year, when you've had time to work out a moral framework and possibly a costume. The first two days, when you've just discovered you can do something nobody else can and you still have to go to work on Monday. What actually happens in that window?

You test it. Obviously. You test it somewhere nobody's watching, and then you test it somewhere somebody is, because a power nobody notices is barely a power at all. Then - and this is the bit the comics skip - you use it for the nearest available convenience. The queue. The parking space. The vending machine that ate your coins in 2019 and has never apologised. Nobody's first act with telekinesis is tectonic. It's getting the remote without standing up.

And after convenience comes the grudge. Every one of us carries a short, private list of people who deserve a small comeuppance. The colleague who takes credit. The neighbour with the leaf blower. The bloke who parks across two spaces with the serene confidence of a man who has never once been told no. Give a normal person a genuine advantage and that list stops being hypothetical very quickly. Not murder, not mayhem. Just a slightly flat tyre. A laptop that dies mid-presentation. Justice, scaled to fit.

That isn't cynicism about people. It's how power works at every size. Promotions, money, a bit of local fame - the first thing anyone does with a new advantage is fix the irritations closest to them. Superpowers would just be the same pattern with the safety catch removed. The real question was never "would you be a hero?" It's how long you'd spend in the petty phase, and whether you'd notice when it stopped being funny.

Because that's the part I find genuinely interesting. Small revenges feel harmless right up until they don't. Each one is justified on its own terms - he had it coming, nobody got hurt, it was barely anything. But a power that's only ever answered to your own sense of fairness has no outside check on it. There's no line manager for this. No regulator, no code of conduct, no one to say "that was a bit much." You are the only judge, and you're also the defendant, and the court is in a very good mood because it just learned to fly.

This is why the classic superhero origin story has a trusted mentor, a dead relative or a convenient moral lecture in the first act. Somebody has to install a conscience before the power gets comfortable. Remove that scaffolding and the story stops being an adventure and becomes something closer to a character test - which, I'd argue, is what we're secretly asking when we pose the question at all. What would you do with superpowers is really what would you do if nobody could stop you. That's not a fun question at parties. It's a much better question in fiction. (I've written before about why we love vigilante stories - this is the uncomfortable engine under all of them.)

There's a second, quieter problem too. Anyone ordinary who suddenly became extraordinary would stop being ordinary to the people who care about such things. Power attracts attention, and attention attracts interest from people who'd prefer the power - or you - didn't exist. The petty phase is the one moment you have the gift to yourself. After that, it belongs to the plot.

So here's my honest answer. With superpowers, I'd like to think I'd end up somewhere decent. But I know where I'd start, and it involves a parking space.

A novel about this

That gap - between the brochure answer and the honest one - is where 22:22:22 Frequency Shift lives. Toby Steele is night-shift IT support in Milton Keynes: quiet, overlooked, on the receiving end of a workplace bully, fond of heavy metal and very used to being invisible. At 22:22:22 on the 22nd of February 2022, a server freeze sends him into the server room, and he walks out having run a piece of dormant code buried decades earlier by a Bletchley Park codebreaker. Suddenly he speaks languages he never learned, can handle himself in a fight, and can feel - and bend - frequencies nobody else can sense.

What makes it work is that Toby doesn't immediately become a hero. He becomes a man with a lot of overdue grievances and, for the first time in his life, the means to address them. The vigilante arrives later, and so does a privately funded outfit called the Department for the Prevention of World-Changing Technology, which takes a very dim view of ordinary men with extraordinary abilities. If you've ever answered the superpower question honestly, you'll recognise him. That's the uncomfortable bit.

FAQ

What superpower do most people say they would want?

Flight and invisibility top almost every poll, with teleportation and mind-reading close behind. What's telling is that the answers split neatly into freedom (flight, teleportation) and advantage (invisibility, mind-reading). Very few people pick a power purely for helping others, even when they claim that's what they'd use it for.

Would most people use superpowers for good?

Probably, eventually - but not first. The honest first use of almost any power is personal: convenience, comfort, settling a score. Doing good tends to arrive later, after the novelty and the grievances have been worked through. The interesting question is how much damage gets done in the gap.

Is there a novel about an ordinary person who suddenly gets superpowers?

22:22:22 Frequency Shift is exactly that. Toby Steele is an overlooked night-shift IT worker who runs a piece of dormant code at 22:22:22 on 22 February 2022 and comes out of the server room with languages he never learned, combat skills he never trained and the ability to feel and bend frequencies. His first instincts are human-sized rather than heroic, which is the whole point.

Why do superhero stories skip the awkward early stage?

Because it's unflattering. The montage of a hero discovering their powers is usually played for fun, but the realistic version - someone with no training, no code and a long list of grudges - is closer to a character study than an origin story. The stories that linger in that stage tend to feel more honest.

Where should I start with the Toby Steele series?

Start with book one, 22:22:22 Frequency Shift, then move on to 23:23:23 Power Shift. The first book sets up how Toby gets his abilities and the people who'd rather he didn't have them; the second assumes you've lived through that.

More like this in The Reading Room →

← All posts